Would A Court of Law Affirm the Historical Jesus?

There is a fellow on the Internet who has been promoting the idea that no court of law would affirm the existence of Jesus Christ based on the available evidence. I refuse to debate him on this issue as it is such a silly claim.  Would a legal court affirm the existence of Jesus?  No they would not.  But neither would they affirm the existence of Alexander the Great, Caesar Augustus or Constantine the Great.  Why?  Because legal courts do not go around affirming the existence of historical figures.  That is not what they do.

The question of how courts would deal with the historical evidence is completely irrelevant.  The question is: what would professional historians do with the evidence.  I don’t mean just conservative Christians or zealous atheist historians but historians across a wide range of religious and philosophical positions.  And how would the historians respond?  Professional historians, almost unanimously, accept the historicity of Jesus Christ, just as they do for Alexander, Augustus and Constantine.  We need to keep this discussion focused and keep it as a historical question and not a legal question.

FAQ on Christianity for the Unbeliever

Originally posted by Frank J. Fleming:

How long have Christians been around?

While many people see Christians as a brand new and quite scary thing, records show Christians have been around since at least the 1950s, and maybe even much earlier.

—

What are their beliefs based on?

It’s a book called “The Bible.” It’s full of thousands-of-years-old religious writing, which Christians believe to have been written by men inspired by God. It’s very long.

—

I see many Bibles are labeled “Holy Bible.” What if I got a non-holy version?

Immediately return it for a refund.

—

The Bible is full of really old values, with lots of outdated views on things like sex. Do Christians actually follow this thing?

Indeed they try. Their view is that while society and technology change, the fundamental nature of man doesn’t, and neither do the values God gave us. Thus, the Bible is something they find relevant and expect people to read and follow many years into the future, like Harry Potter.

—

Don’t Christians know how weird and old-fashioned following the Bible makes them? Everyone else is fine with swearing, sex on TV, and abortion. Why do they have to be so different?

To Christians, following the ways of God is more important than fitting in with societal norms. Thus they are gladly counter-cultural.

—

So they’re like hipsters?

Yes, except everything they do is unironic.

—

There’s some really weird stuff in the Bible, like [quote of strange-sounding rule from Leviticus or Deuteronomy]. The Bible sounds stupid, and people shouldn’t listen to it.

Parts of the Bible can sound weird in isolation, but it takes lots of study to understand the Bible and how the Old Testament relates to the New Testament.

—

But don’t Christians just pick and choose what parts of the Bible they want to follow? Like [quote rule from Leviticus or Deuteronomy that Christians are unlikely to follow].

Christians do not follow much of what is known as the “Mosaic Law.” Much of the reasoning for this is addressed in the book of Hebrews.

—

Okay, so if I just check that out, I’ll find the answer and… wait a second! You almost tricked me into reading more of the Bible! I only need to know enough about it to mock it!

Almost got you. When trying to trip up Christians with quotes from the Bible, just be aware you’re unlikely to find anything they aren’t already aware of, since they read that thing religiously.

—

And don’t Christians know we now have science, which has replaced religion, and that there is no more need for Jesus, since we have lasers and rockets and other science stuff?

Science covers physical and temporary things, while religion covers spiritual and eternal things, so Christians still feel religion is very important — even more important than science.

Read More

Source: pjmedia.com

Curious why when Target, Starbucks, Nike, Amazon, Levi’s, Microsoft, Google, Apple and jcpenney publicly supported gay marriage, it never sparked a controversy…

Maybe Christians are tolerant after all?

Top